I just got the best phonecall from my boatyard project manager. Basically:

"Hey, Alex. When you came over here, did the boat move in reverse when you had the throttle in forward? No? Okay, we just have to fix one little thing..."

When they re-pitched my Max Prop, they re-assembled it set for right hand rotation instead of left hand rotation. Pretty funny, huh?

At least backing into my slip should be easier!