I made the switch to self tailing last year. When I first asked Harken for their recommendation to replace the Barient 25's they also suggested the B32.2ST but after I ordered/received them I found that they were considerably smaller than the 25's, so much so that the base didn't even cover the old holes (maybe the were recommending replacements for the secondary winches). I asked Harken again and they responded (I believe it was Mike Lee) that the correct size to replace the Barient 25 is B44.2ST. The 44 is a very good replacement. Though the bolt pattern isn't the same as the barient, the base will cover the old holes. As for the choice between self tailing and that other way, there really insn't much of a choice in my opinion. My wife is the primary crew on our boat and it was far and away the best "Christmas gift" I ever gave her. Seriously, she has commented often how much easier, enjoyable, etc. it is with the self tailers. I purchased them through Boat U.S. Special Outfitting Service. Got a pretty good deal. Hope that helps.
Steve sullivan
Temptation # 311
