Those harken sheaves appear to be too small re diameter. Rigtite one pictured is 1.75 in.
http://rigrite.com/Spars/SparParts/Sheaves.html#2 OD Sheaves
These are the choices that size that rigrite offers in that size:
1 3/4" Delrin Sheave - 1/2" wide, 5/16" ID: PP-S7D8-5:
Molded Delrin Sheave for use with rope. Sheave is 1 3/4" OD x 1/2" (.490") wide x 5/16" ID. With Rope Groove.
1 3/4" Aluminum Sheave - 1/2" wide, 3/8" ID: K-9951W-6:
Black Anodized aluminum Sheave is 1 3/4" OD x 1/2" wide x 3/8" ID. With wire/rope V-groove.
1 3/4" Aluminum Sheave w/ Integral Bronze Bushing - 1/2" wide, 1/4" ID: K-198-7AB4:
Anodized Aluminum Sheave with integral Oilite Bronze bushing. Sheave is 1 3/4" OD x 1/2" wide (w/ bushing) x 1/4" ID. With wire/rope V-groove.
1 3/4" Aluminum Sheave w/ Integral Bronze Bushing - 1/2" wide, 5/16" ID: K-198-7AB5: Anodized Aluminum Sheave with integral Oilite Bronze bushing. Sheave is 1 3/4" OD x 1/2" wide (w/ bushing) x 5/16" ID. With wire/rope V-groove.
1 3/4" Aluminum Sheave w/ Integral Bronze Bushing - 1/2" wide, 3/8" ID: K-198-7AB6: Anodized Aluminum Sheave with integral Oilite Bronze bushing. Sheave is 1 3/4" OD x 1/2" wide (w/ bushing) x 3/8" ID. With wire/rope V-groove.